New York City's public schools lost about 23,000 students this year, nearly 3% fewer than the year before. The numbers come from preliminary data the city Education Department released Monday, as reported by Chalkbeat New York and the New York Daily News. That leaves the nation's largest school system with about 766,900 students in kindergarten through 12th grade as of the Oct. 31 count. The Daily News put the K-12 loss at 23,018 students.
The drop raises a hard question about money. Schools get most of their funding based on how many students they have. So when enrollment falls, budgets usually fall too. Since the pandemic, though, the city has shielded schools from those cuts. The policy is known as being "held harmless." An analysis by Chalkbeat found the cost reached nearly $290 million this year, about double what it took before, the Daily News reported. Chalkbeat also reported that the city has spent nearly $2 billion since 2020 to prop up budgets at shrinking schools. Those are different measures: one is this year's cost, and the other is the total since 2020.
Officials would not say whether they will keep the policy, Chalkbeat reported. Winding it down could be politically explosive. Schools might have to cut after-school and enrichment programs. Over time, they could have to let go of teachers. When former Mayor Eric Adams tried to phase the policy out, the pushback was so strong that City Council members apologized for backing him, and the decision was later reversed, Chalkbeat reported. In his first budget deal, Mayor Zohran Mamdani kept school budgets whole. Still, Chalkbeat noted that some experts call this unfair, because it lets shrinking schools spend far more per student than other schools.
Counting the city's preschool programs, total enrollment was 863,100, down about 2.6%, or 22,760 students, the Daily News reported. The total fell by slightly fewer students than the K-12 count because preschool enrollment rose a little. A new program added 2,000 2-year-olds, and more 4-year-olds signed up for prekindergarten, Chalkbeat reported. The Daily News said the 2.6% drop set a record for the largest single-year decline since the pandemic, topping last year's 2.4%.
Several things are driving the losses, Chalkbeat reported: falling birth rates, families leaving the city, and a slowdown of immigration into the five boroughs under President Donald Trump. A recent report by City Comptroller Mark Levine tied the drop to fewer school-aged children living in New York, pointing to record-low birth rates and high costs, the Daily News reported. Over the past decade, the city has lost about 200,000 students, nearly 20%, according to Chalkbeat. The trend is not unique to New York. Chalkbeat reported that 30 states have seen public school enrollment fall since 2014, and large systems in Los Angeles, Chicago, Philadelphia, and Houston are facing sharp drops too.
Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels has warned that the city will need to look harder at closing or merging schools too small to offer a full range of courses, Chalkbeat reported. The city is already proposing to close two small schools in Harlem and one in Brooklyn. It also wants to merge two sets of schools in the Bronx and Brooklyn. The Panel for Educational Policy is expected to vote on those plans over the next two months, Chalkbeat reported. "We've started to have conversations in communities," Samuels told the Chancellor's Parent Advisory Committee last week, according to Chalkbeat. "It doesn't mean it's not going to be tough sometimes, but they have been going pretty well."
The pressure is likely to keep building. Chalkbeat reported that by the 2034-35 school year, the city predicts its student population will fall by another 130,000. That projection comes from the School Construction Authority. The latest numbers are preliminary and could still change, the Daily News reported. More students could enroll before the year ends, or officials could revise the data during auditing. Neither the mayor nor the chancellor commented on the data in the department's release, the Daily News said.
